DDR Semi-final Match-up: 4

[BLueSS]

The top 2 songs with the most votes from this match-up will move on to the finals.

Vote for the top TWO entries by posting in this thread.
You MUST vote for two files
You may vote in your own match-up.

- Love SYMPHONY
- Our songs
- Gibold (Scandalous Unltd. Remix)

[Juub005]

Love Symphony
Our songs

[Lisek]

- Love SYMPHONY
awesome song, one of my favourites in this contest
- Our song
it's ok, song is pretty fun, but less than Gibold
- Gibold (Scandalous Unltd. Remix)
remainds me of official DDR songs, plays nice and it's fun

[sanchny]

- Love SYMPHONY
Epic and fun.
- Our Songs
If I were plural, this would be our songs.
- Gibold (Scandalous Unltd. Remix)
I loved the very beginning with the freeze arrow and two eights at the end, as well as when the file kicked in and the section with 12ths, but I couldn't get into the rest of the file and it left me wanting more.

[JukuGuy]

Love SYMPHONY
Gibold

[Telperion]

Love Symphony
Our Songs

I was really split between Our Songs and Gibold. I wasn't a fan of the BREAK DOWN-ish foot placement in Our Songs, but I preferred it to the somewhat boring placement of Gibold. I also like the second-heaviest chart in Our Songs better.

[Jinxie]

Love Symphony
Gibold

[Oni-91]

Love Symphony
Gibold (Chewi, if you can read this, don't use the NAOKI font for anything other than NAOKI logos. Ta.)

[pyroko]

Love Symphony
Gibold

[Miki]

Love Symphony
Gibold

[will-i-am]

love SYMPHONY
Gibold (Scandalous Unltd. Remix)

Juub made a fun one here and I've grown to like Gibold. sanchny has done much better imo.

[Super_Ray]

Love Symphony
Our songs

[The Period]

I disliked the whole 3 files.

So I think I should vote for the less worst.

Love Symphony
Gibold...
....
because Our Songs were very very very trilled and boring. Gibold has some interesting patterns but seems too Itg like to me.

AND SORRY 4 MY BAD ENGLISH! Thanks.

[hellrazor]

Judged by hardest single chart only.
#1 - Love Symphony (Just plain brilliant, this file is well stepped and such a good song, it will go far).
#2 - Gibold (File is okay, steps leave something to be desired, seems like the chart was rushed or just not finalized).

FAIL: Our Song (Song is okay, nice and fast, video is cute, but the patterns are not pad friendly such as the fast turns at beat 190-195, I hate when people use this pattern (three arrow spins) especially at this speed, it's not fun, I'd love to see a video showing how to play this song without double-stepping, otherwise please try to make your chart pad-friendly).

[Kewing]

V - Love Symphony. Impressive with some polishments here and there, slightly less karaoke and empty spaces, and it would be on of the top 3 of the competition by far.
V - Gibold. Nicely, although a bit overdone in places.

X - Our songs. While I appreciate you didn't conisder going karaoke for most the of song, the foot placement and flow seems to be a tad bit all over the place.