hellrazor wrote:Yeah, I did that in B1 as well, 1 point per double step. There may not have been a file that was so bad with double-steps as there was in B2 (I believe Gangnam Style was the worse and it was pretty bad). I think my justification should stand, the more double-steps the less I enjoy the file, if there were 8 in a chart I really REALLY do not enjoy the chart at all and I feel like it deserves 2/10. If there were just 2 or 3 it's not so bad, 5 is poor (although I probably should up-rank that 1/10, it was a good chart and I contemplated breaking my own philophy, however it's 0/10 Standard chart was REALLY bad and deserves it). Yes it's a technical way to judge the files but it also directly relates to my enjoyment of the chart, you'll notice I did not take away points for spins that I liked, but I did take away for spins I didn't like (1 point per each there as well), I think my judgements were quite fair even if I only was judging the play-ability of the chart and the accuracy of the notes to the music (simply start with a 10 and for every error deduct 1 piont). I also stated that in the next rounds I'll increase my judging criteria to include more than just the technical aspects of the charts.
I had a
much longer post but as fate would have it be, that tab got closed.
Hellrazor, your views (despite as much as you think they aren't) are
extremely biased and you have a severe predisposition against legitimate types of steps. The bias is so extreme against "double stepping" and "bad spins" that your judging is creating an extremely skewed and unfair judging environment for this tournament.
I'm doing something I don't recall ever doing.
Hellrazor, due to your extreme biases, all of your reviews are not being considered for judging.
This extends to the next rounds, as well as bracket 1.I was hoping your bracket 2 judging wasn't going to be more "point off for every double step" but it was just more of it, and it's to be honest a horrible way of judging. Your judging before that was even worse, of marking songs off simple because you didn't like the music.
You are extremely biased, and it's as simple as that. Your reviews are not fair, and will not be considered for this tournament.
I will not be reversing this decision, and if you want to stick around you still can, as long as you're not going to try to defend your insane justification for making the tournament unfair.
This is the last BEST-mix, and the last DDR simfile tournament I'll be doing, ever. This series is going to go out with a fair competition, and not an extreme "anti-double step" bias.
---------------
Bracket 1 will be rescored without hellrazor's reviews.
All of the files that originally moved on will still move on.Any files that would have moved on will ALSO move on.
There will still be a wildcard.
:)