1) Did you read feedback about your file (from judges or PR) BEYOND simply looking at the scores you got?
Yes!
2) Did you believe the feedback was accurate, or were they making crap up?
Judge #2 seemed to be way off
http://r21freak.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=1630
3) Have you ever used feedback from other tournament files you have entered to make your file better in ways you hadn't previously been aware of?
No
and the last one
4) Was there any feedback from this tournament you will actually use in making your next tournament file? - and if so, where did you get that feedback from?
Not much. Even after doing really good with OSC5 ITG division, I'm still contantly experimenting differently and trying to see how will the community react when I make stepfile in different ways.
Experiment conclusions from previous contests:
-Live bagpipe bands (OSC2) = makes people's ears bleed, total hatred from Neko
-Live Chinese pop concert (OSC3) = not many people like this type of music, despite good steps
-My own remix of Jingle Bells with tons of BPM gimmicks (christmasmix): that alone killed the stepfile, and later release tamed down the gimmicks
-My own remix of a song from Doom (video game mix): surprising did very well.
-Black metal (OSC4 ITG): goes pretty well with people, although it's not really a genre that will become people's favorites
-The classic star wars theme song (TV and movie mix): Not liked by the public
-Cutie love anime song with challenging expert steps (OSC4 DDR): that chart alone bombed the whole stepfile
-The overstepped Emerald Sword (OSC5 ITG) with simplified steps and inconsistent rhythms: to my surprise this worked really well.
-Generic eurobeat with random rhythms in the opening/ending (OSC5 DDR): Only 2 judges, that don't really count (even if it did pretty well). Most of the PR's say that the synth sections' rhythms are too random, but Lilina (the one that gave my best-mix entry a 12/50) liked this one alot and gave me 9.5/10.
-My own composition (Stepmix #1): hardly any comments. BOO! How well did I compose the song? How well did I make steps to the song I composed?
-an o2jam song with 16th-filled expert (Late night love): that chart didn't quite work, and quality of my steps seemed to begin deterorigating. Since that chart is an extra, the rest of the stepfile performed decently.
-Moogleism-ed gothic rock (Rock mix): 10 foot expert steps = no go, although the rest did decently
-Power metal with messy 10 hard and 13/14 foot expert (Rock mix): didn't work.
-"Song of xxx" o2jam song with annoying girl (Cheesemix 4): People hated the song. Period.
-Fast anime ending featuring a DDR singer filled with heavy crossovers (best-mix #1): Half of the PRs didn't like it, the other half sort of liked it. Complete bomb by Lilina.
-Excessive handplants mixed with huge bunch of turns, and "made up rhythms" (r21fream pad comp #1): didn't work